Taylor Swift’s music isn’t just a collection of songs—it’s a timeline of growth, storytelling, and reinvention. From her country roots in Fearless to the indie vibes of Folklore and the reflective themes of Midnights, each era has its own unique flavor. What better way to celebrate her journey than by creating a cookbook challenge inspired by her albums?
In this post, I’ll walk you through the concept of cooking your way through Taylor’s eras, pairing cookbooks recipes from some of the best cookbooks with the vibes of each album. Whether you’re a Swiftie or just love a good kitchen project, this challenge is all about creativity, nostalgia, and delicious food.
After you read through the challenge, let me know what I got wrong by leaving a comment and what cookbook you really think represents which era.
1. Taylor Swift (Debut Era): Down-to-Earth Comfort
Vibe: Sweet and grounded, with a touch of southern charm.
Cookbook Pairing: Magnolia Table by Joanna Gaines
Taylor’s debut album captures the simplicity of small-town beginnings. Think cozy comfort foods like Chicken Pot Pie or Fluffy Biscuits with homemade jam. These recipes celebrate the warmth of home, just like her early tracks.
Magnolia Table is infused with Joanna Gaines' warmth and passion for all things family, prepared and served straight from the heart of her home, with recipes inspired by dozens of Gaines family favorites and classic comfort selections from the couple's new Waco restaurant, Magnolia Table.
2. Fearless: Romantic and Timeless
Vibe: Sparkling, youthful, and full of heartfelt moments.
Cookbook Pairing: The Joy of Cooking (Classic Edition)
With hits like “Love Story” and “You Belong With Me,” Fearless feels like a celebration of timeless classics. Pair this era with a cookbook that’s equally enduring, tackling recipes like Golden Pound Cake or a perfectly creamy Risotto.
In the nearly ninety years since Irma S. Rombauer self-published the first three thousand copies of Joy of Cooking in 1931, it has become the kitchen bible, with more than 20 million copies in print. This new edition of Joy has been thoroughly revised and expanded by Irma’s great-grandson John Becker and his wife, Megan Scott.
3. Speak Now: Bold and Whimsical
Vibe: Story-driven with an adventurous spirit.
Cookbook Pairing: Dorie’s Cookies by Dorie Greenspan
For an era that tells bold stories like “Enchanted” and “Dear John,” baking feels like the perfect match. Try recipes that are as intricate and whimsical as the songs—like Sparkling Ginger Molasses Cookies or a playful take on French Macarons.
Over the course of her baking career, Dorie Greenspan has created more than 300 cookie recipes. Yet she has never written a book about them—until now. To merit her “three purple stars of approval,” every cookie had to be so special that it begged to be made again and again.
4. Red: Rich and Emotional
Vibe: Passionate, intense, and full of contrasts.
Cookbook Pairing: Dinner: Changing the Game by Melissa Clark.
This cookbook is perfect for channeling the emotional highs and lows of Red. Much like a breakup, it’s filled with moments of intensity, yet offers the possibility of transformation through comforting, creative meals. With recipes that are straightforward yet deeply satisfying, Dinner: Changing the Game invites you to rediscover the joy of cooking for yourself after a tough breakup, with dishes that focus on both nourishment and indulgence—perfect for those healing moments when you need something familiar but elevated.
Dinner has the range and authority—and Melissa Clark’s trademark warmth—of an instant classic. With more than 200 all-new recipes, Dinner is about options: inherently simple recipes that you can make any night of the week.
5. 1989: Chic and Modern
Vibe: Polished, upbeat, and city-inspired.
Cookbook Pairing: The Modern Proper by Holly Erickson and Natalie Mortimer
Taylor’s 1989 is her breakout into pop perfection, and it pairs well with fresh, trendy recipes. This cookbook captures the sleek sophistication of city living, with recipes that are trendy, flavorful, and effortlessly elegant. Perfect for channeling Taylor’s confident and modern 1989 energy, it offers approachable dishes that elevate everyday meals into something truly special.
The Modern Proper will expand your “go-to” list and help you become a more intuitive, creative cook. Whether you’re a novice or a pro, a busy parent or a workaholic, this book will arm you with tools, tricks, and shortcuts to get dinner on the table. Every ingredient is easy to find, plus you’ll find plenty of swaps and options throughout. Each of the 100 recipes (some all-time fan favorites and many brand-new) includes prep time, cook time, and quick-reference tags.
6. Reputation: Edgy and Powerful
Vibe: Dark, unapologetic, and confident.
Cookbook Pairing: The Korean Vegan Cookbook by Joanne Lee Molinaro
For Reputation, you need bold flavors and a little spice. Recipes like Kimchi Fried Rice or Spicy Gochujang Noodles match the album’s fiery, no-holds-barred energy.
Joanne Lee Molinaro has captivated millions of fans with her powerfully moving personal tales of love, family, and food. In her debut cookbook, she shares a collection of her favorite Korean dishes, some traditional and some reimagined, as well as poignant narrative snapshots that have shaped her family history.
7. Lover: Bright and Playful
Vibe: Pastel hues, romantic, and full of joy.
Cookbook Pairing: Sweet Laurel: Recipes for Whole Food, Grain-Free Desserts by Laurel Gallucci.
This cookbook is as sweet and heartfelt as Taylor’s Lover era, with recipes that embrace indulgence in a wholesome, nourishing way. Perfect for creating dreamy desserts to share with loved ones, it’s full of pastel charm and heartwarming flavors that make every bite feel like a celebration of love.
From the beginning, Sweet Laurel has been about making sweet things simple. The recipes here are indulgent yet healthful. They use just a few quality ingredients to create delicious desserts that benefit your body; all of these treats are paleo, and many are vegan and raw. From Matcha Sandwich Cookies to Salted Lemon Meringue Pie to Classic German Chocolate Cake, these treats are at once uncomplicated, beautiful, and satisfying, made only with wholesome ingredients such as almonds, coconut, cacao, and dates. Here, too, are basic staple recipes to keep with you, like grain-free vanilla extract and vegan caramel, and fancy finishes, like paleo sprinkles and dairy-free ice cream.
8. Folklore/Evermore: Cozy and Nostalgic
Vibe: Storytelling, rustic, and introspective.
Cookbook Pairing: The Homemade Pantry by Alana Chernila
These sister albums are perfect for cooking rustic, homemade dishes that feel like they belong in a quiet cabin. Recipes like Hearty Vegetable Soup or Freshly Baked Bread reflect the albums’ grounded and cozy vibes.
In her debut cookbook, Alana Chernila inspires you to step inside your kitchen, take a look around, and change the way you relate to food. The Homemade Pantry was born of a tight budget, Alana’s love for sharing recipes with her farmers’ market customers, and a desire to enjoy a happy cooking and eating life with her young family. On a mission to kick their packaged-food habit, she learned that with a little determination, anything she could buy at the store could be made in her kitchen, and her homemade versions were more satisfying, easier to make than she expected, and tastier.
9. Midnights: Reflective and Sophisticated
Vibe: Late-night musings, deep emotions, and polished melodies.
Cookbook Pairing: Martha Stewart’s Baking Handbook
For Midnights, dive into elegant, late-night indulgences. Try recipes like Chocolate Espresso Tart or Caramelized Onion and Goat Cheese Tartlets. These dishes feel as sophisticated and reflective as the album itself.
Every new book from Martha Stewart is cause for celebration, and with Martha Stewart’s Baking Handbook, she returns to bring the pleasures of baking to readers at every level, from beginner to expert and beyond. A culinary compendium packed with more than 200 foolproof recipes for the best baked goods, Martha Stewart’s Baking Handbook takes readers by the hand and guides them through the process of creating an irresistible variety of cakes, cookies, pies, tarts, breads, and much more.
The Challenge
Now it’s your turn! Cook your way through Taylor Swift’s eras by pairing each album with recipes from your favorite cookbooks. Whether you go in order or pick an era that matches your mood, this challenge is all about creativity and connection.
Are you ready to cook through Taylor’s eras? Share your progress or your favorite pairings in the comments!
Leave a Reply